Cioppino: a favorite recipe from San Francisco CA

In 2005 I attended a WebCT software conference in San Francisco California. The last night of the conference some friends and I had dinner at a restaurant on Fisherman’s Wharf. At this restaurant I enjoyed on of the best dishes I have ever eaten. The dish was kind of a seafood gumbo: there were huge shrimp, tasty crab, and oysters. Two slices of San Francisco’s famous sourdough bread accompanied the dish — which I used to soak up the wonderful sauce that the seafood sat in. The sauce really was the best part of the dish – it was very savory and salty. Man it was good!

CioppinoSadly, I never could remember the name of the restaurant (or the name of the dish) and I did not have a receipt since my friends picked up the tab. A few weeks ago I decided to search for the restaurant and the recipe. Using Google Earth I was able to find the restaurant’s location. Next, I turned on the business info overlays (I love Google Earth!). The name of the restaurant was Tarantino’s. Next, I found Tarantino’s web site using Google search. Browsing their online menu, I was able to discover the name of the dish I had so enjoyed: Cioppino. So, back to Google search — I began to search for a recipe for Cioppino. I was thrilled when I found the Cioppino recipe from a 1949 New York Herald Tribune article posted on a listserv. My family and I tried the recipe that weekend. I think the secret to the savory sauce is the white wine, and the combination of fresh seafood/water and the tomato base. I have cleaned up the text and recipe and included the final version below (a photo of the Cioppino we prepared is attached to this message):

From John Mariani’s ENCYCLOPEDIA OF AMERICAN FOOD & DRINK:

cioppino. A fish stew cooked with tomatoes, wine, and spices, and associated at least since the 1930s with San Francisco, where it is still a specialty in many restaurants (1935). The word is Italian, from a Genoese dialect, _ciuppin_, for a fish stew, and the dish seems to have originated with the Italian immigrants of San Francisco, who often used the crabmeat available in the city’s markets. From THIS WEEK magazine, NEW YORK HERALD TRIBUNE, 13 March 1949, pg. 54, col. 2:

HOW AMERICA EATS

by Clementine Paddleford

SAN FRANCISCO: Supper on Fisherman’s Wharf

“Cioppino,” a California creation, is a strange and wonderful mixture of seafare. Here’s how to make it:

SAN FRANCISCO’s blue bay stirred in uneasy ripples. Little fishing boats cast purple shadows as they rocked themselves to sleep there by Fisherman’s Wharf. Gill netters, purse seiners, trollers, crab boats, day’s work done, were bedded down for the night. I sat in a corner of Tarantino’s Restaurant, its outer wall of clear glass, overlooking the harbor, looking into the West, all America at my back. There was Golden Gate Bridge, an arabesque in steel, delicate as spider’s webbing against the coming night. I could see lofty Mt. Tamalpais. “What’s this?” “Your bib, madam,” said the waiter, tying a cloth of white around my neck. In red stitched lettering the bib announced “I’m eating cioppino.” The words were scarcely digested when the stew arrived. The first fragrant fumes wreathed up to make friends with the nose. I poked into the dish with an exploring fork, a strange gathering of seafare–oysters, lobsters, crab, clams. Then the first rapturous taste of the sauce-steeped garlic bread–ummm, delectable sauce! This cioppino, pronounced “cho-PEEN-o,” is a bouillabaisse of sorts, a kissing cousin of the bouillabaisse (Col. 3–ed.) of Mediterranean cities, but this a California creation found nowhere else. Don Sweeney, Jr., and Gene McAteer, the Erin lads who operate Tarantino’s, told me the name is a corruption of the Italian word cuoco, which means “cook.” A fisherman’s concoction made first by the Genoese who man the small fishing boats which chug in and out of the harbor. The dish is made over charcoal braziers, made of whatever the day’s catch supplies. It may be shellfish entirely, or seafood and shellfish, the various kinds washed, cleaned, layered in the pot; then a rich garlicky tomato sauce added and the collection cooked. The fishermen usually leave the shellfish in the shells; restaurants and home cooks more often remove the meat. It’s all a matter of taste.

Add What You Please

VISIT San Francisco and eat cioppino or make it at home using the day’s market catch. Here we give you the recipe exactly as it’s made in the Tarantino kitchen. All but the romance; the sight of drying crab nets, the music of water lapping the gray timbers of the pier, the scent of night fog rolling in from the Pacific to enclose the city of hills in a gray wall. A green salad is just right with this meal-in-a-bowl. Allow at least a half-dozen paper napkins apiece. Those who live inland may not be able to get the full assortment of shellfish mentioned, but never mind, do as Western cooks do–add what you please. As to seafood, boned striped bass and halibut, cut in two-inch (Pg. 55, col. 2–ed.) pieces, are favorites for cioppino. Start the layering with the fish on the bottom, then tuck in the rest, any which way, but layered as to kind.

Tarantino’s Cioppino Sauce

  • 4 cloves garlic, minced
  • 1 medium onion, finely diced
  • 1 green pepper, finely diced
  • 1 leek with leaves, finely diced
  • 3 green onions, finely diced
  • 3 tablespoons oil
  • 1 No. 2 can solid-pack tomatoes, chopped fine, with juice
  • 1 8-ounce can tomato puree Pinch of thyme
  • 1 bay leaf Salt and pepper to taste
  • 2 cups white table wine

Sauté garlic, onion, green pepper, leek and green onions in oil until golden.

Add tomatoes, tomato puree, thyme and bay leaf.

Cook slowly two to three hours, covered, stirring frequently.

Add salt and pepper to taste; add wine; cook 10 minutes longer and pour over shellfish.

Shellfish Assortment

  • 16 littleneck clams in the shell, uncooked
  • 4 medium oysters in the shell, uncooked
  • 8 large shrimp, shelled, uncooked
  • 2 small lobsters or 1 large, cooked
  • 2 medium West Coast crabs or the East Coast hard-shelled crabs, cooked

Allow clams and oysters to stand in fresh water for one hour to remove sand.

Scrub shells thoroughly.

Split lobsters in half in shell.

Split the crabs in half; disjoint the legs.

Place in layers in a deep saucepan.

Cover with sauce; simmer, covered, 15 minutes, adding water if necessary.

Heap into soup plates, garnish with garlic-toast fingers and serve from the kitchen.

See that each bowl has some of each kind of fish and a big helping of the piping sauce.

Yield: 4 portions. Many are the versions of this famous stew. Virtually anything goes if the sauce is good. R. A. Carey, a real-estate broker of San Anselmo, Cal., whose week-end (Col. 3–ed.) hobby is cooking for crowds, told us his way with the dish. He removes the fish from the shell, less messy eating.

3 Comments

  1. Don Madden August 29, 2008
  2. Michael VanPutten September 23, 2008
  3. David September 23, 2009

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

11 − five =